Skip to main content

Identifying, Analyzing and Comparing Historical Arguments based on two short essays

Write a 3-4 page essay comparing and contrasting the arguments offered by John Lewis Gaddis and Walter LaFeber about the origins of the Cold War.  You should start by identifying the argument of each author.  Then try to explain why Gaddis and LaFeber come to such different conclusions.  In trying to address these issues, you might consider questions like the following.  (Address only those that seem relevant.)

* Do the two historians make the same assumptions about the motivations and security interests of the U.S. and the Soviet Union?  If not, how does that affect their respective arguments?
* Do the two historians give the same attention/weight to the actions of the U.S./Truman and the Soviet Union/Stalin?  If not, how does that affect their arguments?
* How do the two historians describe the personalities of Truman and Stalin?  How, if at all, does that affect their arguments?
* Is there anything on which Gaddis and LaFeber agree?  Do you see any similarities in their arguments?

The bulk of your paper should compare and analyze the two arguments.  However, once you have done this, you may choose to briefly evaluate the arguments.  Do you find one or the other more convincing?  If so, why?

Please spend some time ensuring that your paper is well organized and grammatical, that you use the active (rather than passive) voice, and that you begin paragraphs with strong topic sentences.  Your paper should be typed and double-spaced in 12-point font with standard margins, and should employ footnotes rather than in-text citation.



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Netanel (1996) talks about the NIEP theory approach to copyright and the democratic paradigm. Explain the difference between these in your own words. Lessig (2008) talks about read-only (RO) and read/write (RW) culture. How can copyright facilitate both of these?

chapter one Introduction A ‘‘Largely Ignored Paradox’’ The u.s. supreme court has famously labeled copyright ‘‘the engine of free expression.’’1 Copyright law, the Court tells us, provides a vital economic incentive for the creation and distribution of much of the literature, commentary, music, art, and film that makes up our public discourse. Yet copyright also burdens speech. We often copy or build upon another’s words, images, or music to convey our own ideas effectively. We cannot do that if a copyright holder withholds permission or insists upon a license fee that is beyond our means. And copyright does not extend merely to literal copying. It can also prevent parodying, remolding, critically dissecting, or incorporating portions of existing expression into a new, independently created work. Consider The Wind Done Gone, a recent, best-selling novel by African American writer Alice Randall. Randall’s novel revisits the setting and characters of Margaret Mitchell’s classic Civil War...
Post a Comment
Read more

1. Good time management for project managers includes initiating contact with key stakeholders only when there is a valid issue to deal with. -True -False

1. Good time management for project managers includes initiating contact with key stakeholders only when there is a valid issue to deal with. -True -False Click here for more on this paper ……. Click here to have a similar A+ quality paper done for you by one of our writers within the set deadline at a discounted 2. A project manager should identify a problem in terms of its alternate solutions so that team members can more easily reach a decision on how to solve the problem. -True -False 3. Networks are mutually beneficial alliances that are generally Click here for more on this paper ……. Click here to have a similar A+ quality paper done for you by one of our writers within the set deadline at a discounted governed by the law of: a Supply-demand b Brooks’s law c Reciprocity d A squeaky wheel e Risk-reward Click here for more on this paper ……. Click here to have a similar A+ quality paper done for you by one of our writers within the set deadline at a discounted 4...
Post a Comment
Read more

How did life in the British colonies contribute to creating a unique American identity?

How did life in the British colonies contribute to creating a unique American identity? How do you see that identity manifested in modern American society? 200 to 300 words Click here for more on this paper ……. Click here to have a similar A+ quality paper done for you by one of our writers within the set deadline at a discounted Assignment status :  Solved by our Writing Team at EssayCabinet.com. MAKE YOUR ORDER
Post a Comment
Read more